Catching Up With Gentleman Jack S2


June is LGBTQ Pride Month, so we’re featuring fabulous queer frock flicks each Thursday. Queer folks have always been part of human history, long before there were words to describe these identities and orientations. But now we can and will say GAY! (and LESBIAN! and BI! and TRANS! and QUEER!) proudly, whether or not others try to legislate or pray it away.


A second season of Gentleman Jack (2019-) just finished airing in the U.S. and U.K.. I ended up watching them all out of order because I was staying in London for a bit, thus no recapping like last time. But because of that trip, I was able to catch costume designer Tom Pye again on the phone and talk about the second season a little bit. So let’s admire some of his work and hear what went into it!

Gentleman Jack (2022)
Gentleman Jack (2022)

Tom Pye’s sketches for one of Ann Walker’s dresses, posted on his Instagram.

Frock Flicks: We love how the costumes are a little different from season one. What was your point of view for this season?

Tom Pye: The diary picks up just one month after season one, but I knew that I wanted to come back to it and do something new and fresh, just to keep myself interested and excited with it and that the audience would want to not see the same old costumes. They’d want to move on. But I also had to make sense of the diary, since it’s only one month later. So I straddled that in the first episode by having lots of the same costumes — which wasn’t that easy as they’d gone about everywhere. And then by episode two, having lots of new looks.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Anne (Suranne Jones). Photograph by Aimee Spinks/HBO.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Ann (Sophie Rundle). Photograph by Aimee Spinks/HBO.

Tom Pye: I feel like, when couples move in together, you do get a shift, and when people are married, you get a sense of security. People’s wardrobes start to morph into each other. I think there’s a maturity in Ann Walker, she’s the one who shifted the most. She’s a lot more mature than the bright pinks and pale blues and lots of lace pelerines in season one. She’s now like a married woman. She’s more mature in her color palette, she’s more complex.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Photograph by Sam Taylor/HBO.

Tom Pye: Coming to season two, complexity and nuance were what I was interested in playing with. In season one, my main job was just to tell who everyone was because we had 100 characters to explain and get their status over to an audience very quickly — landowner, worker, cook — so people understood who everyone was. In season two, because everyone knows who everyone is, I could be a bit more playful and a bit more subtle and a bit more nuanced.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Tom Pye: I also was thinking about what effect on the Shibden residents Ann Walker moving in would have. So I had quite a bit of fun with Marian Lister about how she would be affected by a feminine woman like Ann Walker entering the house and how that might change the way she looks as well.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Marian (Gemma Whelan). Photograph by Aimee Spinks/HBO.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Marian (Gemma Whelan) & Jeremy (Timothy West). Photograph by Aimee Spinks/HBO.

Frock Flicks: One character who has a larger role this season is Mariana and she has some amazing outfits…

Tom Pye: She is my favourite one to dress. I just like that character and the sort of opulence and the arrogance of her. So her color palette was more lush and darker and richer. I really let rip on Mariana, and Lydia is great to work with. I mean, I couldn’t wish for a better cast to work with.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Marianna Lawton (Lydia Leonard). Photograph by Aimee Spinks/HBO.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Tom Pye’s sketch for one of Mariana’s dresses, posted on his Instagram.

Gentleman Jack (2022) Gentleman Jack (2022)
Gentleman Jack (2022)

Tom Pye’s sketches for Mariana’s dressing gown, posted on his Instagram.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Frock Flicks: Any other new or expanded characters that you had fun with?

Tom Pye: Tib was fun. Tib’s an all new character who pops up in episode two and a little later. Lovely actor to work with. Larger than life figure, very famous in the diary. That was quite challenging because at the end of season one, in one of the scripts, Tib turned up, so I’d already started designing her.

From the diary, she’s described as very outdoorsy, sort of a woman you’d imagine dressed in tweed these days with a shotgun over her shoulder and pheasant in her hand. She was an outdoorsy, country type. But we meet her for the first time in a French high-class restaurant. So that was quite a challenge to think how do I get across who this woman is when I have to meet her in evening wear in Paris and then in the Louvre the following day.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Tib (Joanna Scanlan). Photograph by Sam Taylor/HBO.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Tom Pye’s sketches for one of Mariana’s dresses, posted on his Instagram.

Tom Pye: In the Louvre, I could get a sense of that sort outdoorsy-ness, so I gave her a kind of earthy palette. I think there’s a half a pheasant wing in her hat and various bits of dead animal hanging off her. And a whole bird in her hair in the restaurant. We just went for a really bold color palette to give an idea of this woman who really doesn’t care what others think.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Pheasant on her hat.

Gentleman Jack (2022)

Some kind of jeweled animal paw pin on her collar.

Frock Flicks: Any ideas about season three?

Tom Pye: We only finish this season in 1835, I think, so there’s still five more years of her life available. I have no idea if there is another season, but she wrote six million words so there’s a lot of diary left to go and more travel and all sorts of stuff that goes on.

Frock Flicks: What else are you working on, if you can say?

Tom Pye: Another Sally Wainwright project, The Ballad of Renegade Nell. It’s set in another obscure period, which I’m thrilled to do. And typical Sally, it’s got people from the lowest walks of life right up to the aristocracy to the queen, which is great fun for me because I get to do all stratas of society. It makes for really interesting costuming and contrasts.



What do you think of the costumes in season two of Gentleman Jack?


About the author

Trystan L. Bass

Twitter Facebook Website

A self-described ElderGoth, Trystan has been haunting the internet since the early 1990s. Always passionate about costume, from everyday office wear to outrageous twisted historical creations, she has maintained some of the earliest online costuming-focused resources on the web. Her costuming adventures are chronicled on her website, TrystanCraft. She also ran a popular fashion blog, This Is CorpGoth, dedicated to her “office drag.”

7 Responses

  1. Yosa Addiss

    I love the costumes so much!!! It makes me so happy to see Anne in navy blue and the embroidery on her waistcoats has me in fits needing to replicate. The progression of the characters into more mature tones as the story gets more and more about property ownership is wonderful.

    My one gripe: Has anyone else noticed how very very large all of the tea service items are? Their teacups are enormous! I know I am biased as I have done research and have old porcelain, but those teacups, seriously. What were they thinking.

  2. thedementedfairy

    I enjoyed the costumes [mostly] WAY more than I enjoyed the series as a whole. It was all rather meh to be honest, and Anne was so bloody unpleasant, that even the rather watered-down asides to the camera lost all humour. There she was, gaslighting Ann and bullying everyone, then getting a leg over Mariana. I have not read the diaries, but was aware that Miss Lister was a rather difficulty character to like, but…it was boring. We found ourselves yelling at Ann Walker to clock her one and walk out…

    • Trystan L. Bass

      I tend to agree. Having read much of the published diaries, Lister seems like a contradictory & often not very nice person, so at least S2 was accurate to that. But it wasn’t great fun to watch :(

  3. Roxana

    If poor Marian can’t have a man at least she can have great clothes!
    Anne’s taste remains impeccable, I love that blue military style gown!

  4. heatherbelles

    The costumes are on display at Bankfield Museum, just down the road from Shibden Hall – I need to finish watching the series and then I’m going to tootle across to go see them :)

    (they’ve got an exhibition of historical costume from the same period on too – which I recommend. And not just cos the Museum I work for has lent some pieces for it…)

  5. Susan Pola Staples

    I loved the 2nd season costumes bc of their texture and style, as well as how they showed each person’s character. Ann was becoming more sure of herself, more mature and aware of her surroundings. Her clothes reflect this. I enjoyed Tib so much, I am demanding a Tib spin-off. Marianna still isn’t a favourite bc while Ann is developing a strong sense of worth. Marianna just wants to break up the Ann/Anne marriage.

  6. Orian Hutton

    I am drooling. The clothes! The hair! What absolute joy. Oh, if all historical productions could be like this. Heaven.