I’m kind of in the minority here at Frock Flicks, because I actually like historical mystery shows and will watch them just for the hell of it, not even for costume content. Which is fortunate, because the costume content usually sucks in these shows.
So, now that I have access to BritBox on Amazon Video, I’m finding all of these shows that never made it across the pond to American audiences, and if there’s one thing that Brits seem to really enjoy, it’s murder-mystery shows and historical miniseries. And occasionally, someone gets the brilliant idea to combine the two and we end up with awesome shows like Cadfael.
In fact, it was because I had been re-watching Cadfael recently that Amazon suggested City of Vice (2008) as something I might enjoy. The premise intrigued me: Henry Fielding (celebrated author of Tom Jones) sets aside his writing to put together a crack team of investigators known as the Bow Street Runners, whose mission is to solve crimes and bring bad guys to justice. And it’s set in the 1750s, so maybe there will be some interesting costume content aside from the standard “rag people” that invariably represent pre-20th-century Londoners.
The series only lasted one season, and I’m halfway through the second episode as I write this and I have to say, I’m conflicted. City of Vice lacks the finesse of, say, Cadfael, but that could also be because it also lacks Derek Jacobi.
And while I know that in real life, John Fielding, Henry’s blind brother, was able to distinguish thousands of people from scent alone, the show’s version of John (played by the non-blind Iain Glen) is just a little too precious for me. Also, the moralizing, while accurate for the period, hits me as somehow “off” — I’m still trying to work through why that is, though.
Anyway, we’re here to talk about the costumes, right? Right. So, costume-wise… Well… It’s a lot of middle-class and working-class menswear. And since the premise of the show is the Fieldings’ work around the demi-monde of 18th-century London, the womenswear so far is either whores or cross-dressers.
Ultimately, this is one of those historical shows where the emphasis is definitely on making historical London look like an absolute cesspool, which translates into everyone looking like Mr. Susan from The Mighty Boosh episode “Monkey Hell.”
Plenty of mud, all it’s missing is some pigs. So unless you’re super-committed to the mystery element, you might give this one a pass.
Opinions otherwise on City of Vice?
Derek Jacobi makes everything better.
Cadfael is hard to beat.
I think that there is a law that says Iain Glenn or Martin Clunes must be cast in every single series/show offered on either BritBox or Acorn. But my question is, why does Blind Brother wear a ribbon across his forehead? Vestigial head-necklace?
I don’t know what the black band really is about but it’s actually in the portrait of the real John Fielding. Could be another way of signaling that he was blind or something.
Never heard of this, but I LOVE CADFAEL.
I love Cadfael (and Derek Jacobi) so much!
I will have to give this a try since I have read the series of mysteries by Bruce Alexander featuring Sir John Fielding. I wonder if this series is based on those.
Gee how did the show acquire Kosh from Babylon 5?
And you’re in error, the addition of Derek Jacobi makes anything a gazillion times better.
Gotta say, this series is firmly in my background costuming TV list, along with Moulin Rouge, Outlander, Amadeus, Harlots, etc. (we need a term for that…). Even bought the DVDs. It’s slow, sure, but there’s something refreshing about it not being all about the aristocracy.
Love Cadfael so much, I took the Cadfael walking tour in Shrewsbury (which is an awesome town).
Mr. Susan! That reference made me LOL!
I tried to watch City of Vice when it was on hulu and couldn’t stick with it. It may have been because the audio was really out of balance, with loud music and quiet speech. Or it may have been the strange emphasis on documentary-likee narration. That along with the moralizing tone reminded me of what the aspects I find most tedious about 18th century novels!
I don’t suppose you guys could be convinced to do a costume review of the Cadfael series?